Very close to the Henryville indeed, but not quite the same.
The US fly has a very pronounced body hackle, and uses traditional quill wings combined with wood duck or mallard fibers, where the Eurpea has no body hackle and uses a whole duck feather (or two) for the wing. But apart from that the flies are surprisingly identical in overall appearance.
The Henryville is a caddis fly imitation like the Europea, created pre-WWII like the Europea. It was originated by Hiram Brobst for use on the the Henryville in the Pocono Mountains in Pennsylvania.
Whether one is inspired by the other or not is unknown to me, but as with many other fly patterns, the chance of two almost similar flies being created independently is pretty high. Especially with generic flies such as these caddis imitations, which after all have to have a caddis profile and therefore inevitably will wind up somewhat identical.
See how to tie the Henryville Special in our video section.
Martin
- Log in to post comments
